login   |    register
ModellTrans Modellbau [ MORE REVIEWS ] [ WEBSITE ] [ NEW STORIES ]

In-Box Review
172
10.5cm ls FH auf Geschutzwagen
10.5cm ls FH auf Geschutzwagen Char B1 (f) Conversion for Trumpeter kit
  • move

by: Andras [ SPONGYA ]

Introduction

The German Army captured a number of French vehicles after the fall of France, which were pressed into service either in their original roles, or after being rebuilt to a different purpose. This must have created a nightmare for maintenance units, but provides a goldmine for modelers who prefer odd-looking vehicles.

The Char B1 heavy tanks, which fell into the hands of the Germans, were unsuited for the war of movement Germany specialized in, hence most of the captured vehicles were used in second line (on the Channel Islands, for example), for training, or were converted. Some were used as flame throwing vehicles, and sixteen were converted into self-propelled artillery, mounting the 10.5cm le FH 18/3 gun. The resulting SPG is one of the most unique-looking armored vehicles I have seen, and makes for an interesting part of any model collection. (To be perfectly honest, World of Tanks brought this SPG to my attention. It's one of the most fun premium artilleries to play in the game, but the reason I bought it was because it looked strange.)

the set

This Model Trans Modellbau conversion was designed for the excellent 1/72 Trumpeter Char B kit. The conversion comes packed in a blister pack, which should make shipping and handling a relatively safe process for the resin parts. (Some of the smaller parts did break off from their casting blocks during shipping, and the thin resin armor shields were chipped, unfortunately.) It consists of 21 well-cast resin parts, all of which have good detail, and very few casting imperfections (the notable exception is the muzzle brake). As usual with resin conversions, the kit does not come with detailed instructions. What you get is a few color photographs of the assembled kit, and a drawing of the Trumpeter hull showing where to cut the plastic away.

Most of the parts make up the gun itself, which is the most difficult part of the assembly. (Reference photos of the gun will come very useful, as the photos of the assembly provided are not very clear.) The quality of the gun barrel is good enough (no warping, no bubbles), but the muzzle brake does have casting issues. The liquid resin got into the cavities, filling them up. I did my best to clean it up, but it is difficult to hollow it perfectly.

The armor plating which protects the fighting compartment is very delicate, and careful handling will be required. The fighting compartment was a headache. This conversion provides a flat surface with no-slip pattern, which can be installed easily enough. However, I cannot comment on the historical accuracy. I was unable to find reference drawings or photos of the actual vehicle’s fighting compartment. What I found was that different conversion sets/scratchbuilt conversions picture this area differently. Some are open to the driver’s compartment; some are completely sealed off, just like this conversion. One thing is for sure: it would probably need a radio set, and a few storage boxes.

conclusion

The building time with cleanup is literally two hours; most of which will be spent with the assembly of the gun, and the modification of the Trumpeter hull. This is a very fast and easy conversion.

Armory has a similar conversion kit which uses PE parts for the armor. It does cost more, however, and personally I don't really like to work with photoetched parts. (Mostly because I'm not very good with them.) Competition is good, however, because it gives us choices: an easy and cheaper resin, or a more difficult, and more expensive mixed conversion set.

SUMMARY
Highs: Good casting, fast assembly.
Lows: Some chipped parts, some details are (probably) missing, some issues with the molding.
Verdict: Good value for the money.
Percentage Rating
75%
  Scale: 1:72
  Mfg. ID: MT 72396
  Suggested Retail: 12 EURO
  PUBLISHED: Dec 09, 2013
  NATIONALITY: Germany
NETWORK-WIDE AVERAGE RATINGS
  THIS REVIEWER: 85.05%
  MAKER/PUBLISHER: 79.25%

About Andras (spongya)
FROM: BUDAPEST, HUNGARY

I am a biologist by trade, and as a hobby I've been building scale models for the last twenty years. Recently I started to write reviews of the models I bought. These reviews are written from the point of view of an average model builder; hence the focus is on quality of the model, how easy it is to...

Copyright ©2019 text by Andras [ SPONGYA ]. All rights reserved.



Comments

Andras, agreed that this is a marvellously "wrong" looking vehicle, and consequently looks great. On the interior, maybe the radio would have been inside the tank hull fighting compartment, as the superstructure isonly there for the big gun, and looks quite small as far as those things go; I imagine there's room inside the tank for radio set, ammo, maybe? I wondered the same about the Dicker Max I'm building, is it known what the interior is like with any accuracy? Incidentally that Trumpeter kit has no radio set, but again the driver is separated from the rear compartment by a bulkhead. Anyway, interesting review, hope to see you finish it off maybe?
DEC 09, 2013 - 12:27 PM
Thank you for your kind words I am building this thing for the WoT campaign...
DEC 10, 2013 - 12:19 PM
(Sorry, did not know ENTER would send this message.) Anyhow, one model I saw in 1/35 had the radio in the "turret". But then it had the original turret ring, and the interior was accessible through the ring. (The ammo was stored in the tank itself...) So it's confusing. It would have been nice to have found some photos, but I was unable to find any references or drawings. Next stop: KV-5 and SU100Y.
DEC 10, 2013 - 12:21 PM
   

What's Your Opinion?


Photos
Click image to enlarge
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move