login   |    register
MK35 Editions [ MORE REVIEWS ] [ WEBSITE ] [ NEW STORIES ]

In-Box Review
135
Norman Farmhouse
WWII Norman House
  • move

by: Bill Cross [ BILL_C ]


introduction

A constant challenge for AFV modelers is “what the hell do I do with the finished vehicle?”

The default answer seems to be “put it on a piece of wood with a brass plaque or something.”

Trying to build dioramas vastly increases the pain-in-the-seat of building models, mostly because the challenge is making the scene look like it’s NOT a modeling diorama.

And one of the biggest challenges for that kind of realism in dios is the generally low level of buildings that I see out on the market. Many seem to be holdovers from model railroading, and either aren’t to-scale, or else just look crappy. Not universally, but the elephant in the room of dioramas is the challenge of finding good buildings. Is it any wonder most of the outstanding dios you see have built-from-scratch structures?

Well, one of the companies that have been making progress in this area is MK35 Editions. They have released a series of French edifices and accessories, including walls and fences, that look as though they were taken from a period photograph of the Normandy countryside (the company also makes resin figures). One of their largest items is a Norman farmhouse. The photos on their website were too attractive for me to resist.

what you get

The building comes well-packed in a 13” x 8.5” by 4” and includes:

9 resin window & door pieces
9 ceramic walls and roof of the house.

the review

Unfortunately, traveling all the way from France via Washington State, there was quite a bit of breakage, including one resin door frame part that broke off entirely. The good news is it was easy to glue back together. Half of the ceramic pieces arrived cracked, however, some in several places. Gluing those parts back together hasn’t been difficult, though filling in the cracks has added a level of complication I hadn’t bargained on. I didn’t imagine plaster buildings are going to travel that far very well, so it’s par for the course as far as I’m concerned, and no reason to hold it against the manufacturer or the US Mail.

We haven’t gotten a lot of these items in-house here at Armorama for review purposes, probably due to the high cost of shipping, so I thought I would take the time to look at this particular building I purchased for myself. Overall, the MK35 buildings are very realistic-looking in my opinion, without the “suggestion” of a structure that you find with, say Miniart. The building is also particular to the subject, and does not use a lot of standardized parts that turn up in all their other kits. The Norman farmhouse says "Normandy," and would not be appropriate for, say, Germany in 1945 or the Eastern Front.

The casting for the “ceramic” portions is very good, with lots of detail in the stones that make up the house or its slate roof. One of the things I didn’t like is the detailing on the ceramic pieces was only done on one side. I don’t have a problem with that for the interior surfaces, but the house has two walls that extend outward, so this means you must either hide them behind trees or somehow replicate the obverse side. I chose to carve out bricks and mortar with a hobby knife, which was tedious, though hardly rocket science.

One challenge in acquiring this building is the weight of shipping. MK35 flatly refused to ship it to me from France because they would need to charge over €40! They offered to give me some resin figures to make it more worthwhile, then directed me to R&J Enterprises in Washington, who got it to me for $61. That works out to less than it would cost me just to purchase it from France (there’s some hocus-pocus about refunding the VAT to my credit card, but you get the picture).

The finished result is very realistic. However....

It took me some effort getting there. The roof is too large for the structure and hangs too far over the bottom edges. That meant measuring, then cutting off about an inch along the bottom of each of the two roof sections. The roof is thin, and I broke one in half when I did not keep it flat enough when scoring the portion I wanted to break off. My advice is to work on a flat, hard surface and be careful about how much you bear down.

Another problem is the resin shutters: about half of them are too large. Again, this means cutting them down to size or taking a file to the windows.

instructions & painting guide

Uh, there are no instructions.

There are some photos in the brochure, that's all. You’re on your own, folks. Fortunately, the nine ceramic pieces are more or less self-explanatory: four walls, a roof and two extensions of the back wall, plus a “stoop” for the front door. The resin pieces are easy to figure out: shutters over the windows and an ornate wooden door that will need some "glass" to complete the look.

The painting guide is very interesting: a wash of Humbrol 29 over the ceramic parts, let dry, then scour with a Scotchbrite pad. I would caution you, though, to be careful you don't scour off some of the fine detailing. A pure painting solution might be preferable, and is the path I'm taking.

conclusion

This isn’t an OOB solution for your diorama needs, yet the level of quality for this building is superior to many others on the market. It looks exact, as if MK35 nailed the essence of a Normandy farmhouse. While that might limit its applicability to one campaign, Operation Overlord is one of the most-popular and important campaigns of the war, with lots of opportunities for this building to enhance both Allied and Axis dioramas. I would definitely recommend this building as long as you're aware of the challenges of bringing it to life. The only other choice would be scratch-building it, and that is waaaay more work than I want to undertake.

So many kits to build, so little time....
SUMMARY
Highs: Excellent casting detail; realistic look of the subject matter.
Lows: Heavy to ship. Lack of instructions. Parts need to be trimmed, and don't fit right.
Verdict: A very realistic addition to a Normandy diorama, but not an "out of the box" solution. Grudgingly recommended, but recommended highly.
Percentage Rating
75%
  Scale: 1:35
  Mfg. ID: B018
  Suggested Retail: $55
  PUBLISHED: Mar 25, 2011
  NATIONALITY: France
NETWORK-WIDE AVERAGE RATINGS
  THIS REVIEWER: 90.08%
  MAKER/PUBLISHER: 86.89%

About Bill Cross (bill_c)
FROM: NEW JERSEY, UNITED STATES

Self-proclaimed rivet counter who gleefully builds tanks, planes and has three subs in the stash.

Copyright ©2019 text by Bill Cross [ BILL_C ]. All rights reserved.



Comments

Hi Bill Good review. I really like Mk35's buildings but the postage can be quite high. I reviewed their Destroyed Normandy Wall which would probably look great added onto your house At the time I bought it I also bought a good few figures to make the postage worth my while
MAR 25, 2011 - 04:56 AM
Thanks, Pat. I think we get spoiled with the great OOB kits that come on the market, some of which practically fall together. Your wall WOULD look great, but I'd have to swap you too much to cover the postage, LOL! Is it plain on the reverse side, or does it have "bricks" on the back, too?
MAR 25, 2011 - 10:31 AM
great review Bill, really well written. is buying directly from Mk35 the only way to get my hands on their products? some of their items may make it onto my wish list. cheers, bd.
MAR 25, 2011 - 11:12 AM
Plain on the back so you would have do as you did and scribe the brickwork in. Casting one sided plaster pieces from one piece moulds is really easy. I think with detail on two sides you need to work harder to eradicate the airbubbles so there'd be a lot more wastage- making the kits even more expensive
MAR 25, 2011 - 11:59 AM
Thanks, Bruce. I got mine from R&J Enterprises. Not only did I probably save money over buying from France, but Joy is such a, well, joy to deal with. They're very helpful people and honest as the day is long. Pat, you're right about making an expensive kit even more expensive. The plaster is soft enough one can score it with a dull X-Acto blade.
MAR 26, 2011 - 12:01 PM
   

What's Your Opinion?


Photos
Click image to enlarge
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move