login   |    register
Eduard [ MORE REVIEWS ] [ ">WEBSITE ] [ NEW STORIES ]

Built Review
132
Eduard Bf 109 E-7
Bf 109E-7 Trop Profipack
  • move

by: Bill Cross [ BILL_C ]


Originally published on:
AeroScale



introduction

Clearly the dominant fighter of the early air campaigns in Europe was the BF 109. A design of Willy Messerschmitt for the Bayerische Flugzeugwerke (hence the designation BF, with the company name changed to Messerschmitt AG in 1938). Other great fighters such as the Spitfire or Mustang that would eventually best the 109 were either in their early stages of development or still on the drawing board when the E-series variant (dubbed “Emil”) was both terrorizing the skies of Spain during its Civil War, and winning air races, including the 1937 speed record. In an era when retractable landing gear and enclosed canopies were still rare, the 109’s innovations set it ahead of other fighter designs. Its triumph was complete in the skies above the Blitzkrieg that crushed Poland and then France.

Intended as a short-range interceptor, the 109’s inherent flaws emerged when asked to take on the role of bomber escort during the Battle of Britain in the Summer and Fall of 1940. The most damning was its lack of range or even the capability of carrying an extra fuel tank. The basic design continued to evolve, and the Emil would eventually be replaced by the “Friedrich” and then the “Gustav” (the most-produced variant) and finally the “Kurfürst” (“prince elector”). By the end of the war, the 109 was the most-produced German plane, accounting for nearly half of the Third Reich’s aircraft production. Those 109s that survived the war or which had been exported prior to it joined planes manufactured under license in Czechoslovakia and Spain to fly on, even into the 1960s.


1/32nd Bf 109's

The 109 has attracted tremendous interest in 1/32nd scale lately from both kit manufacturers and modelers, especially the Emils. First Eduard, then Trumpeter and now Dragon have all introduced kits with more promised. Eduard’s first foray was the E-1, but the kit attracted a firestorm of criticism over the shape of its canopy (too narrow); so much so, the company was forced into remedial action. Subsequently Eduard has released an E-4 and an E-3; now it is offering the last version of the Emil, the E-7 Trop (for Tropen or “tropical”) which served mostly in North Africa and Italy. The E-7 was the last version before an extensive redesign in the F variant. A bomb/fuel tank pylon was introduced, with the Emils gradually being shifted away from interceptor work to the role of fighter-bomber, especially on the eastern front.

the kit

The kit is packed in the usual Eduard pasteboard box sporting a cover painting of a dogfight with two RAF P-40s somewhere over a Mediterranean coastline. It includes:

6 sprues of greenish-tan plastic
2 frets of PE
1 sprue of clear plastic canopy parts plus additional canopy
1 sheet of paper canopy & wheel masks
Painting mask placement guide
Sheet of Cartograf decals
16 page instruction booklet with four painting schemes plus a guide for the stencils

Sprue photo's by Jean-Luc Formery can be found HERE.


the review

This was the first Eduard plastic kit I’ve built, and I must say it left me with mixed emotions. The quality of the molding, the detailing and the packaging, including instructions and decals, were all exemplary. But the fit! Why is it so hard for manufacturers to come up with a wing root that attaches to the fuselage without extensive filling and sanding?

The good news is that in a Profi-Pack you get everything you need except glue and paint. The photo etch is just right (intake screens, cockpit details and instrument dashboard), plus masks for the canopy and the wheels. I especially like the cockpit details which give the kit a realistic look. The PE seatbelts are the standard we’ve come to expect from Eduard, and the dashboard is a revelation: you’ll never go back to hand-painting or decals in this scale afterwards.

Another serious bug with the kit is the engine: Eduard includes a beautifully-detailed styrene engine but you can’t use it unless you leave off the cowling. This might not sound like a problem for those of you who always build “buttoned-up,” but it actually is: I chose to skip the engine in my build, but then the air intakes in the cowl and the exhaust openings for the nose-mounted MGs are empty. Not the kind of thing IPMS judges take kindly to. The solution is to make sure you include the machine gun magazines and fashion something behind the nose intakes.

A strong plus are the separate control surfaces. The 109’s tail surfaces, for example, rested at a downward angle of 45 degrees when parked, so this avoids the need to cut off the control surfaces like on Hasegawa 109s. The wheel wells are nicely-done, if lacking some of the detail of Trumpeter’s PE wheel bay surfaces, but unlike in their E-4, the intake screens are properly-positioned and the support rods for the radiators are provided.

One curious choice by Eduard is to have the front trim tabs extended. You will have to cut down the mounting pins if you want the tabs in-place. I have seen very few photos with them extended while parked, so I’m at a loss why Eduard decided to make this decision instead of letting modelers make the adjustment themselves.

Eduard has a set of resin tires for their Emils out, but the styrene ones in the kit are more than acceptable. The one-piece propeller saves agony about blade positioning, and the drop tank is very good with an acceptable mounting pod. No PE tabs are provided, but they are usually left off even resin upgrades.

Finally, the canopy. A new, less-narrow canopy is provided, though the only hint of this is a separate sheet showing the pieces that should now be used and those that should be discarded. Take note, else you end up building the wrong one. The results are very good from my perspective.

painting & decals

The kit offers five camouflage variants (though the last must be downloaded from Eduard’s web site).
• 3./JG 27, Ain-el-Gazala, Libya, 1941 (RLM 78 undersides, and RLM 79 on the top with RLM 80 mottling)
• Stab I./JG 27, Ain-el-Gazala, Libya, 1941— Obt. Ludwig Franzisket, JG 27, Libya, June 1941 (same colors with yellow nose & tail)
• 2./JG 27, Ain-el-Gazala, Libya, 1941—“Black 8” (same colors with white belly band)
• 2./JG 27, Ain-el-Gazala, Libya, 1941- “Black 3” (RLM 71 & 02 on the upper and RLM 65 on the undersides, likely darkened with RLM 71 stripes on fuselage)
• I./JG 27, Ain-el-Gazala airfield, Libya, Summer 1941-- Eduard Neumann, Gruppenkommandeur (“commanding officer”) of I./JG 27 with seven kill marks (Abschußbalken) on the rudder)
conclusion

One criticism of Eduard’s kits is their cost, so the Profi-Pack is designed to bring together a great kit and the PE you want for it in one box. The results are very good, but could be excellent. If the fit problems weren’t there, this one would score in the highest percentiles.
SUMMARY
Highs: Good one-box kit with everything needed except paint & glue. Great details, including the usual PE.
Lows: Poor fit at wing roots (what else is new?). Can't build with engine if cowling is in-place.
Verdict: Despite its limitations, a very good rendering of this important Emil.
Percentage Rating
85%
  Scale: 1:32
  Mfg. ID: 3004
  Suggested Retail: $64
  Related Link: 
  PUBLISHED: Feb 11, 2011
  NATIONALITY: Germany
NETWORK-WIDE AVERAGE RATINGS
  THIS REVIEWER: 90.08%
  MAKER/PUBLISHER: 88.43%

About Bill Cross (bill_c)
FROM: NEW JERSEY, UNITED STATES

Self-proclaimed rivet counter who gleefully builds tanks, planes and has three subs in the stash.

Copyright ©2019 text by Bill Cross [ BILL_C ]. All rights reserved.



Comments

Thanks, Andy, for taking this one "live." Thanks, too, Nick, I appreciate the kind words. It's a challenging kit to wrestle to the ground, but the results are very nice if you can stomach the work, LOL!
FEB 12, 2011 - 05:38 AM
Great work Bill, your build looks really well done. Not bad for a self-proclaimed treadhead :-) Take care JIm
FEB 12, 2011 - 06:19 AM
Thanks, Jim. I will have a built review of Pacific Coast Models' Hurricane with metal wings in the next few days. I enjoy building the larger scale planes, and have a number of them in my stash. You guys teach me a lot here, and I'm glad to have a break from disputes about the right transmission covers on M4A1 Shermans, LOL.
FEB 13, 2011 - 05:42 AM
Hi Bill I'm jealous at the prospect of your Pacific Coast Hurricane! The kit's been on my wish list since it came out. All the best Rowan
FEB 13, 2011 - 12:16 PM
Rowan, it takes some wrestling to the ground, especially the wing root issues. But it builds up into a honey. Battle of Britain is my passion-- have the RoG JU-88 in the stash, and Mal is making up masks for a Spitty Mk.I. Trying manfully to resist the lure of the new DML Emil, so I guess you could say we're even in terms of envy, LOL!
FEB 14, 2011 - 11:53 AM
Bill, which Spit do you have? What squadron are you planning to model? i think we're all pretty lucky, after all, we all deplete our stashes one kit at a time, good time to e a modeler!
FEB 14, 2011 - 01:15 PM
I have the old, but very nicely-done Revell/Hasegawa 32 scale Mk.I/II. The fuselage needed rescribing, but it wasn't horrendous (try doing a Bf110 from RoG which has ALL raised panel lines). I got some resin weighted wheels and the Eduard Mk.V PE upgrade, though I didn't do the open flaps. Probably should have, but I'm happy with the results. It turned out very nice. Mal Mayfield has promised me some masks so I can do a Spit from 602 Squadron flown out of Westhampnett by Osgood "Pedro" Hanbury in August 1940. I'll be doing a "mask build" showing the marking of the completed kit.
FEB 15, 2011 - 08:06 AM
well if I'm not mistaken, that was the kit i finished and posted here a bit ago on my adversaries post. Is the cockpit devoid of any real detail? If s we probably have a match here. I had to scratchbuild most of it and throw away the rest. keep us posted :-) Jim
FEB 15, 2011 - 01:10 PM
Not sure, Jim, but I think it's a different kit (Ia, as opposed to I/II). I got the 411 from Arie Donker, who did this excellent build. The Eduard Mk.V interior upgrade took care of any problems with the cockpit, though I also used the Barracuda resin seat with leather backpad to replace the oversize seat that comes with the kit or the Eduard set.
FEB 16, 2011 - 03:38 AM
   

What's Your Opinion?


Photos
Click image to enlarge
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move